Re: Undo last commit?

Hi Mike,

Mike writes:

I do think that git needs polishing in this way. It was designed by a
very intelligent programmer... however they can sometimes be the worst
at user interface design. I think a lot of people are missing out on
how great git is because of the learning curve, and also the slightly
odd naming conventions.

"git reset --soft HEAD^" can't be picked up that quickly by a
beginner, but git uncommit would be obvious! So I have to agree with
Holger. Good design makes something intuitive. I have used DVD
recorder / players that are so badly designed that I needed to read
the instruction manual. Something complicated can be designed to such
a degree that people rarely have to read a manual, and they can pick
it up really quickly because it's obvious. If you disagree then you
might need to learn something about good design because what I say
isn't opinion it's a fact. Flame away :)

I completely agree with you.  Git's user interface can certainly be
improved -- we have had many many discussions on this topic (like
{1]).  Unfortunately, the way to go about doing it is not to implement
every little suggestion and introduce more inconsistencies;  Git is
very complex, and changing one little thing requires us to think about
how it'll affect everything else.  Yes, it does seem like a daunting
task, but the interface IS improving slowly and steadily.  You can
help by thinking about how a certain new feature will interact with
every component of Git, and participating in UI discussions.

-- Ram

[1]: http://thread.gmane.org/gmane.comp.version-control.git/175061