Re: [git-p4] Trouble importing all perforce branches into git repository

On Thu, Jun 16, 2011 at 10:28 AM, tumik [off-list ref] wrote:

Did you get it working so that the branch integrates at Perforce show up as
merges in git? I have been trying to do this for tens of hours now and just
can't get it working.. I have tried making the branch mapping both ways, and
even both at the same time but with no success.

I have succesfully imported the two testing branches to git, but if I look
at it in gitk for example, the history is linear and there are no merges
from the other branch (it shows up as a normal commit, without the parent
from other branch, just adding all lines that the merging did). in p4v it
shows up as it should!

git-p4 only uses the branch mapping for the initial commit on a
branch. It does not attempt to detect merges after that point. After
importing to git, merges just appear as regular commits in the
history.

Unfortunately, implementing a general solution for this is
non-trivial. Perforce branches and merges per file, meaning that
partial merges are possible in Perforce. Such states can not be
correctly represented in Git, and depending on your needs, you may or
may not want a particular partial merge to be considered as a git
merge.

There was another script called git-p4raw for importing Perforce
history to git, which does merge detection. It solved the problem by
having configurable rules for what should be regarded as a merge, and
it supported manually reviewing the decisions afterwards (iirc).

One possibly useful feature in git-p4 would be an option to regard
every integration as a complete merge, which shouldn't be too hard to
implement. But this would break every time someone did a single-file
integration between two branches (which happens quite often in my
experience, for cherry-picking changes etc.).

Thomas