Re: [PATCH] Use /etc/mailname for the hostname part of the email address.

On Fri, 6 Jul 2007, Matt Kraai wrote:

From: Matt Kraai <redacted>

/etc/mailname contains the hostname to be used on outgoing email
messages generated locally on Debian systems

I think this is taking us into a bad direction.

The thing is, I actually personally tend to _prefer_ the committer name as 
being "user@hostname" rather than a "real" email address.

It often tells you something much more.

For example, take a look at the kernel archive, and do

	git log --author=torvalds

and notice how the exact author string changes - not just because 
"osdl.org" became "linux-foundation.org", but because it ends up encoding 
which *machine* I did things on.

For example, while I do almost all my work at any time on my "main" 
machine (right now "woody" - not because I'm horny, but because it's an 
Intel woodcrest machine, the way my previous main machine was called "g5" 
because it was an IBM PowerPC G5 machine), but I sometimes do things on 
another machine because that's the machine that showed the problem, or was 
the machine that it got tested on (32-bit x86 things: "macmini" or "evo"), 
or it was just the laptop I use while travelling ("evo" again).

IOW, I don't think the authorship really even _has_ to be seen as a "real 
email" address. The "user@hostname" in many ways is nicer. Sure, when the 
patches come in as emails (which ends up being most of them), it obviously 
ends up being the email, but I don't think that's at all required.

If you actually want to contact the people involved with a patch, you 
should use the "Signed-off-by:" and "Cc:" lines in the commit message, not 
necessarily the author thing!

			Linus