Re: [PATCH] pack-refs: dereference .git/packed-refs if it is a symlink
From: Junio C Hamano <hidden>
Date: 2016-06-15 22:43:06
Peter Baumann [off-list ref] writes:
git-new-workdir creates a new working directory where everything necessary, including .git/packed-refs, is symlinked to your master repo. But git-pack-refs breaks the symlink, so you could accidentally loose some refs. This fixes git-pack-refs to first dereference .git/packed-refs if it is a symlink. While we are it, add some tests to prevent this from happening again.
Because you are only fixing the case where the worktree is borrowing the packed-refs file from a real repository with a symlink trick, and we do not know if somebody had his packed-refs as a symlink to some random place for reasons other than creating a lightweight worktree (maybe there was a mistake), I am wondering if it makes sense to be more strict about the value we read from readlink(). For example, if it does not end with "/packed-refs", doesn't it suggest that the reason because the symlink is there is different from the case you are handling (i.e. it is not a packed-refs symlink in a lightweight worktree that points at the corresponding real repository)? I wonder if in such a case we would want to signal an error, instead of overwriting whatever real file the symlink points at. Or is it too strict and paranoid? I dunno.