Re: [PATCH 3/3] Allow whole-tree operations to be started from a subdirectory
From: Junio C Hamano <hidden>
Date: 2016-06-15 22:42:49
Steven Grimm [off-list ref] writes:
Which is why I think the commands should just cd to the top directory as needed. Doing otherwise is just making the user do pointless busywork. IMO any command that, if run in a subdirectory, currently does nothing but spit out a "hey, you can't run me in a subdirectory!" error is not doing what the user wanted. The user never runs one of those commands hoping to see an error message or to test whether he's in the top-level directory. I can't think of any situation in which I'd want to see that error instead of the --top behavior.
Having said what I said in the other message, I 120% agree with this. The 20% you did not say but I am adding because I really want it to happen is this. I want to make running "git merge" from a subdirectory first cd-up the interactive shell I am typing "git merge" into and then run the command. This is because the reason why I am running one of these "whole tree" operations is because I am done with what I have been doing in the subdirectory I was in, and I am moving onto something different. Of course this cannot be done from within "git merge" command, but perhaps with clever use of shell aliases it might be possible.