Re: sending changesets from the middle of a git tree

On Sat, 13 Aug 2005, Linus Torvalds wrote:

That's correct. Same things apply: you can move a patch over, and create a 
new one with a modified comment, but basically the _old_ commit will be 
immutable.

Let me clarify.

You can entirely _drop_ old branches, so commits may be immutable, but
nothing forces you to keep them. Of course, when you drop a commit, you'll 
always end up dropping all the commits that depended on it, and if you 
actually got somebody else to pull that commit you can't drop it from 
_their_ repository, but undoing things is not impossible.

For example, let's say that you've made a mess of things: you've committed
three commits "old->a->b->c", and you notice that "a" was broken, but you
want to save "b" and "c". What you can do is

	# Create a branch "broken" that is the current code
	# for reference
	git branch broken

	# Reset the main branch to three parents back: this 
	# effectively undoes the three top commits
	git reset HEAD^^^
	git checkout -f

	# Check the result visually to make sure you know what's
	# going on
	gitk --all

	# Re-apply the two top ones from "broken"
	#
	# First "parent of broken" (aka b):
	git-diff-tree -p broken^ | git-apply --index
	git commit --reedit=broken^

	# Then "top of broken" (aka c):
	git-diff-tree -p broken | git-apply --index
	git commit --reedit=broken

and you've now re-applied (and possibly edited the comments) the two
commits b/c, and commit "a" is basically gone (it still exists in the
"broken" branch, of course).

Finally, check out the end result again:

	# Look at the new commit history
	gitk --all

to see that everything looks sensible.

And then, you can just remove the broken branch if you decide you really 
don't want it:

	# remove 'broken' branch
	rm .git/refs/heads/broken

	# Prune old objects if you're really really sure
	git prune

And yeah, I'm sure there are other ways of doing this. And as usual, the 
above is totally untested, and I just wrote it down in this email, so if 
I've done something wrong, you'll have to figure it out on your own ;)

			Linus