# RE: \[RFC PATCH v2 1/5\] mm: Introduce vm\_ops-\>may\_mprotect()

- From: Xing, Cedric \<hidden\>
- Date: 2019-06-10 17:47:56 
- List: linux-security-module
- Page: https://ratatoskr.run/linux-security-module/2019/06/5623736
- Thread: https://ratatoskr.run/linux-security-module/2019/06/5619310/t.md

```text
> From: Christopherson, Sean J
> Sent: Monday, June 10, 2019 8:56 AM
> 
> > > As a result, LSM policies cannot be meaningfully applied, e.g. an
> > > LSM can deny access to the EPC as a whole, but can't deny PROT_EXEC
> > > on page that originated in a non-EXECUTE file (which is long gone by
> > > the time
> > > mprotect() is called).
> >
> > I have hard time following what is paragraph is trying to say.
> >
> > > By hooking mprotect(), SGX can make explicit LSM upcalls while an
> > > enclave is being built, i.e. when the kernel has a handle to origin
> > > of each enclave page, and enforce the result of the LSM policy
> > > whenever userspace maps the enclave page in the future.
> >
> > "LSM policy whenever calls mprotect()"? I'm no sure why you mean by
> > mapping here and if there is any need to talk about future. Isn't this
> > needed now?
> 
> Future is referring to the timeline of a running kernel, not the future
> of the kernel code.
> 
> Rather than trying to explain all of the above with words, I'll provide
> code examples to show how ->may_protect() will be used by SGX and why it
> is the preferred solution.

The LSM concept is to separate security policy enforcement from the rest of the kernel. For modules, the "official" way is to use VM_MAY* flags to limit allowable permissions, while LSM uses security_file_mprotect(). I guess that's why we didn't have .may_mprotect() in the first place. What you are doing is enforcing some security policy outside of LSM, which is dirty from architecture perspective.
```
