Is "rebase" = "Neuaufbau"? My last thought on this wording was "rebase" =
"Umpflanzen".
"Basisumbau"?
I have added both suggestions to the glossary that they don't get lost when
we discuss about non-optimal and/or missing parts within the glossary.
Ralf
From: Michael J Gruber <hidden> Date: 2016-06-15 22:54:13
Ralf Thielow venit, vidit, dixit 05.07.2012 20:16:
quoted
quoted
quoted
Is "rebase" = "Neuaufbau"? My last thought on this wording was "rebase" =
"Umpflanzen".
"Basisumbau"?
I have added both suggestions to the glossary that they don't get lost when
we discuss about non-optimal and/or missing parts within the glossary.
Not the base is being reconstructed, but what's on top of it. So,
"Basiswechsel" would be more appropriate.
But: "Umpflanzen" is really a great term which stays within the context
of trees, roots and branches. Strictly speaking, "Umpflanzen" refers to
something you do at the root level. The corresponding action for
branches would be "Umpfropfen". I think that also conveys the effort
that is sometimes necessary ;)
Michael
On Fri, Jul 6, 2012 at 8:20 PM, Michael J Gruber
[off-list ref] wrote:
Ralf Thielow venit, vidit, dixit 05.07.2012 20:16:
quoted
quoted
quoted
quoted
Is "rebase" = "Neuaufbau"? My last thought on this wording was "rebase" =
"Umpflanzen".
"Basisumbau"?
I have added both suggestions to the glossary that they don't get lost when
we discuss about non-optimal and/or missing parts within the glossary.
Not the base is being reconstructed, but what's on top of it. So,
"Basiswechsel" would be more appropriate.
I agree with you. There is no question what it means, but what are
the best german words for it.
But: "Umpflanzen" is really a great term which stays within the context
of trees, roots and branches. Strictly speaking, "Umpflanzen" refers to
something you do at the root level. The corresponding action for
branches would be "Umpfropfen". I think that also conveys the effort
that is sometimes necessary ;)
"Neuaufbau": it contains the concept of rebase
"Umpflanzen": it contains the concept of rebase
"Umpfropfen": Actually, this word isn't familiar to me. It's a bit
unusual, isn't it?
(but it might contains the concept of rebase)
The whole point is that the user needs to know what it actually meant
in git-context.
If a user read "sie pflanzen gerade um" or "sie pfropfen gerade um", I
don't think that
this is the best solution. I haven't said that "sie bauen gerade neu
auf" is the optimal one,
for me it's better, though.
We really need to discuss (and thats indeed also an issue on other
translation teams), which
git (or SCM) related words we shouldn't translate at all.
Thanks,
Ralf
From: Peter Baumann <hidden> Date: 2016-06-15 22:54:13
On Fri, Jul 06, 2012 at 08:58:21PM +0200, Ralf Thielow wrote:
On Fri, Jul 6, 2012 at 8:20 PM, Michael J Gruber
[off-list ref] wrote:
quoted
Ralf Thielow venit, vidit, dixit 05.07.2012 20:16:
quoted
quoted
quoted
quoted
Is "rebase" = "Neuaufbau"? My last thought on this wording was "rebase" =
"Umpflanzen".
"Basisumbau"?
I have added both suggestions to the glossary that they don't get lost when
we discuss about non-optimal and/or missing parts within the glossary.
Not the base is being reconstructed, but what's on top of it. So,
"Basiswechsel" would be more appropriate.
I agree with you. There is no question what it means, but what are
the best german words for it.
quoted
But: "Umpflanzen" is really a great term which stays within the context
of trees, roots and branches. Strictly speaking, "Umpflanzen" refers to
something you do at the root level. The corresponding action for
branches would be "Umpfropfen". I think that also conveys the effort
that is sometimes necessary ;)
"Neuaufbau": it contains the concept of rebase
"Umpflanzen": it contains the concept of rebase
"Umpfropfen": Actually, this word isn't familiar to me. It's a bit
unusual, isn't it?
(but it might contains the concept of rebase)
The whole point is that the user needs to know what it actually meant
in git-context.
If a user read "sie pflanzen gerade um" or "sie pfropfen gerade um", I
don't think that
this is the best solution. I haven't said that "sie bauen gerade neu
auf" is the optimal one,
for me it's better, though.
We really need to discuss (and thats indeed also an issue on other
translation teams), which
git (or SCM) related words we shouldn't translate at all.
I have to agree with this last sentence. Most of the git gui terms are really
not understandable to me (and even the team I introduced it too). The only way to
actually "guess" what it means is by knowing the position of the buttons and then
getting the actual command from the position.
AFAIK it makes no senes to translate terms like "commit" to "Abzeichen" like it is used
in git gui. I don't know *anybody* here in my IT business environment who uses this word
or even would guess what it means. Everyone is used to the Denglisch Version "committen"
or "einchecken".
But in case you insist of translating this word (which I wouldn't!!!),
may I toss in another suggestion: "Umsetzen"
-Peter
AFAIK it makes no senes to translate terms like "commit" to "Abzeichen" like it is used
in git gui. I don't know *anybody* here in my IT business environment who uses this word
or even would guess what it means. Everyone is used to the Denglisch Version "committen"
or "einchecken".
As far as i can see, "Abzeichen" is only used as translation for "Sign off".
"commit" is translated as "eintragen". So i don't see what your
problem is, actually.
If you have a problem caused by translation, please send a bug-report
to the GIT ML
that we are able to detect and fix them.
Thanks
Ralf